
Our Methodology
How we rank AI coding tools
Key Features
- Innovation decay modeling to reflect tool freshness
- Platform risk assessment for vendor dependencies
- Revenue quality adjustments based on business model
- Technical capability weighting for different use cases
- Multi-source data validation and normalization
- Logarithmic scaling for balanced comparisons
Primary Factors (82.5%)
Agentic Capability
Measures autonomous capabilities, multi-step reasoning, and complex task completion
Innovation
Evaluates breakthrough features, technical advances, and market differentiation
Technical Performance
Benchmarks on SWE-bench, HumanEval, and real-world coding tasks
Adoption
Active users, growth rate, and market penetration metrics
Market Traction
Revenue growth, funding rounds, and business momentum indicators
Secondary Factors (17.5%)
Sentiment
Developer satisfaction, community feedback, and recommendation scores
Velocity
Feature release cadence, update frequency, and innovation speed
Resilience
Platform stability, backup options, and vendor independence
🔄 Innovation Decay
Innovation scores decay over time to reward continuous improvement and penalize stagnation
score = originalScore * e^(-0.115 * monthsOld)
⚠️ Platform Risk
Adjustments based on vendor lock-in, platform dependencies, and business risks
Risk Penalties
- • Recently acquired by competitor: -2.0
- • Platform exclusive (single LLM): -1.0
- • Owned by competing platform: -1.5
- • Regulatory compliance issues: -0.5
- • Funding or sustainability concerns: -1.0
Risk Mitigation Bonuses
- • Supports multiple LLM providers: +0.5
- • Open source availability: +0.3
- • Self-hosting options: +0.3
💰 Revenue Quality
Revenue weighting based on business model sustainability and growth potential
Data Collection Methods
- Direct API integrations with tool providers
- Industry research reports and analyst data
- Official company announcements and press releases
- Developer surveys and community feedback
- Standardized performance benchmarks
Validation Requirements
- All required metrics must be present
- Multiple source verification for key metrics
- Outlier detection and manual review
- Cross-validation with industry benchmarks
Update Schedule
Rankings are recalculated weekly with continuous data collection. Major algorithm updates are versioned and documented.